Microsoft does the right thing. Web developers' heads explode in surprise.

For those who haven't been following the recent drama regarding the proposed web standards behaviour in IE8, here's a re-cap.

  • Microsoft announces that IE8 can render the ACID2 test perfectly in IE8. Web devs get excited.
  • In the name of "not breaking the web" (read: "not pissing off corporate clients that have spent many thousands of dollars on Microsoft CMS, Sharepoint, .NET controls and other web interfaces") Microsoft announce a version targeting mechanism that allows web pages to be rendered using the IE version of choice. So far so good, however, by default, IE8 will render nearly all web pages exactly the same as if it were IE7. Standards-savvy developers would have to opt-in to IE8's standards rendering engine.
  • The web development community splits into two; those that believe the default behaviour is wrong and goes against the very nature of building valid, forwards-compatible websites; and those who believe it is in the best interest of the internets, protecting Microsoft's partners who use thier dodgy web technologies and the vast majority of web designers who still use invalid markup, spacer gifs, layout tables and blink tags.

Now, I fit somewhere in the middle. I believed the default behaviour is wrong, but honestly thought it was not big deal. I understood that Microsoft was protecting their own interests. We've been accomodating IE since the dawn of time, so why stop now.

Anyway, none of that matters any more.

In Microsoft's Interoperability Principles and IE8 on the IEBlog, IE General Manager Dean Hachamovitch has announced:

In light of the Interoperability Principles, as well as feedback from the community, we're choosing differently. Now, IE8 will show pages requesting 'Standards' mode in IE8's Standards mode. Developers who want their pages shown using IE8's 'IE7 Standards mode' will need to request that explicitly (using the http header/meta tag approach described here).

I actually thought it was kind of silly that folks like Jeremy Keith were jumping up and down about the default behaviour, like they actually thought it was going to do anything about the situation. Trying to pressure Microsoft into doing anything would be like trying to convince an elephant to walk through a doorway. It just doesnt fit.

So, colour me flabbergasted. Kudos to Jeremy and others like him for championing for the cause rather than (like myself) be prepared to just grin and bear it. Also big snaps for Microsoft and the IE Team for actually listening to the developer community and making the right decision.


No comments on ‘Microsoft does the right thing. Web developers' heads explode in surprise.’

Comments are closed

Comments on this post have been closed. If you would like to contact me about this post or for any reason, please get in touch.